Archive for October, 2009

Lee & Suzanne - Lessons to be learnt

Wednesday, October 28th, 2009

The BBC showed a programme on Suzanne’s on going plight, you may get found innocent, you may be released from prison, but it doesn’t finish there.

The nightmare goes on and on, with time things fade but it will always be there. The odd fool may still believe the Fools in White Coats, and those that either encourage or allow them to prosper.

A brave lady, the show also covered Angela Cannings when the two met down in Plymouth. It was a great story on their case, with Kyles Grandmother also on. Its a shame more across the land didn’t get to see it.

There should be news soon on what the IPCC (Police Complaints) have to say about Suzannes investigation. I really hope that someone in Policing Training (the NPIA - National Police Improvement Agency) really wants to learn from these cases.

As it destroys those involved, but it also tarnishes Officers careers (or even destroys them), the publics faith in the Police etc. I may have reached the point now were I feel that it is best to approach them with a willingness to resolve the issues, not that it helps us, but at least then it may impact on others.

The same applies to the CPS and of course the hardcore ‘Experts’. Penny Mellor from the Angela Cannings Foundation is digging out lots of things on certain experts and it makes you wonder if one campaigner, can find out some of the things she does, then why don’t the CPS or courts check the backgrounds, qualifications, theories etc?

After Suzannes programme there was a Panorama show on the problems with MAPPA and keeping an eye on Offenders and how many were committing offences on Bail. The Government haven’t been showing how many offences were being committed by people on Bail - you guess why.

Lots more stories of how many cases are coming up due to the expected wash from Baby P’s tragic case.  So much to sort out and with how much interest from the ‘Official Side’ - we will see…. 

Stay safe.

Iain

p.s. You would have thought you would have stayed safe in an RAF Nimrod ‘The Mighty Hunter’. That was until the Defence Budgets were cut so far back we have to bodge it more often than not…still the election is coming. 

                            lest we forget…….

The loss of Ludo

Monday, October 19th, 2009

Hi,

The loss of someone who stood against the many and fought unpopular fights, that others turned away from, has broken today. A name I grew up with and was always aware of, only now do I realise how important he was.

A man who served in the Senior Service on the very dangerous Artic Convoys, forget the risk by U-Boats and German Aircraft, the weather alone was far more ruthless. Brave men who still parade in their white berets to reflect the artic snow and ice. Anyway here is his story…

The author, broadcaster and campaigner Sir Ludovic Kennedy has died aged 89.

A former BBC Panorama journalist, Sir Ludovic spent decades investigating miscarriages of justice, including the case of the Birmingham Six.

He contributed to the abolition of the death penalty and was also president of the Voluntary Euthanasia Society.

He is understood to have died on Sunday at a nursing home in Salisbury, Wiltshire, after contracting pneumonia. He leaves four children.

Sir Ludovic was married to ballet dancer and actress Moira Shearer - star of the Classic film The Red Shoes - for 56 years, until her death in January 2006 at the age of 80. The couple had one son and three daughters.

Tributes have paid by senior figures in the worlds of journalism, law, politics and campaigning.

Executions

As a young man, Sir Ludovic joined the Royal Navy and his ship HMS Tartar was involved in the sinking of the German battleship Bismarck.

After the war, he attended Oxford University and went on to become a successful journalist.

During his career, he carried out his own investigations into a number of high-profile criminal cases.

He sustained his commitments until they were victorious

Gareth Pierce
Human rights lawyer

Obituary: Sir Ludovic Kennedy

Among them was that of Derek Bentley who was hanged for shooting dead a policeman even though someone else pulled the trigger.

His most famous book, 10 Rillington Place, caused a national outcry when it argued that another executed man, Timothy Evans, did not murder his baby daughter.

Sir Ludovic maintained that the serial killer John Christie was responsible, and after a police inquiry, Evans was granted a posthumous pardon in 1970.

Human rights lawyer Gareth Pierce - whom Sir Ludovic worked with on a series of miscarriages of justice - said he was “profoundly committed” to the cases he took up.

“He sustained his commitments until they were victorious,” she said.

Defence lawyer Joe Beltrami, who also worked with Sir Ludovic, said he was the last of the great campaigning journalists but was “very modest”.

“He had great determination to win and he won more often than he lost. I admired the man.”

‘Controversial causes’

Mark Thompson, director-general of the BBC, called Sir Ludovic “one of the giants of post-war broadcasting.

“His integrity and the tenacity of his investigative journalism, particularly where he saw injustice, won him the respect and trust of generations of audiences,” he said.

For much of his life, Sir Ludovic was a member of the Liberal Party and its successor, the Liberal Democrats, and stood unsuccessfully as a Liberal candidate in 1958.

He quit the party in 2001 when the then leader Charles Kennedy refused to endorse assisted dying, and stood for Parliament again unsuccessfully as an independent candidate on a pro-euthanasia platform.

He later rejoined the Lib Dems and current leader Nick Clegg paid tribute to him.

“Ludovic Kennedy was one of the great thinkers of his generation,” he said.

He was a passionate advocate of assisted dying for terminally ill people

Sarah Wootton
Dignity in Dying

“His pursuit of justice and his championing of sometimes unpopular and controversial causes marked him out as a true liberal.”

Scottish First Minister Alex Salmond said Sir Ludovic was “an outstanding broadcaster”.

“He was a lifelong free-thinking member of the Liberal Party, but he was also a long-standing advocate of Scottish independence, and in later life he frequently endorsed SNP campaigns,” he added.

Mr Salmond said although Sir Ludovic had “friends and admirers across the political spectrum, no one doubted his journalistic integrity and independence”.

‘Bit of an anarchist’

Richard Ingrams, co-founder of satirical magazine Private Eye, said that while Sir Ludovic had connections with the Liberal party - and “a very impeccable establishment background” - he was really “a bit of an anarchist”.

“For somebody like that to be engaged in the exposure of miscarriages of justice - it gave him an advantage,” he told the BBC. “He couldn’t be dismissed as a kind of left-wing lunatic or anything like that.”

Sarah Wootton, chief executive of Dignity in Dying - formerly the Voluntary Euthanasia Society - said the organisation was saddened.

“He was a passionate advocate of assisted dying for terminally ill people, whose compassion and vigorous intellect were an asset to the organisation,” she said.

Edinburgh-born Sir Ludovic was a prominent supporter of the British Humanist Association (BHA).

BHA chief executive Hanne Stinson said he was a “progressive campaigner on many fronts” and would be “sorely missed”.

The Future and Inspirations

Sunday, October 18th, 2009

Evening,

It is worrying in more ways than  one to see there are more cases of Child Abuse. No one wants anymore cases of abuse, well no right minded soul anyway. But what is worrying is the knee jerk element. Its bad enough normally, but with the glare of publicity everyone wants to be a hero, but also and more importantly, nobody wants to get it sooo wrong….again!

I just pray that justice finds all, whichever way the scales tip may they be appropriate all the time.

On a lighter note well done to Jensen Button, he has come through after years of trying, it shows if you stick to it things can come out of it and good things at that. Its just a shame the M25 isn’t as clear as some of those circuits.

Talking of even more amazing souls Phil Packer apart from raising millions for Help 4 Heroes, he also supports (at least) 5 other charities, again it shows even through the most awful tragedies, great good can come.

You can be so inspired by people at times and so infuriated by others, the selfish, the greedy, the disrespectful, the morons who urinate on wreaths and taunt our servicemen. They should be sent into the front line - unarmed and just use their rapier wit and cunning against the Taliban.

But Remembrance is coming and we should never forget the debt.

I had the pleasure of meeting a lot of old and new faces at the weekend raising money for local good causes. Albert Einstein once said ‘its all relative’…no hang on it wasn’t that it was “Only a life lived for others is worth living”.

Even when you don’t have much, its good to give, even if its only your time. There were a lot of people giving up their time this weekend and all deserve the thanks of us all and most expect nothing for it, no praise, no social climbing, no nothing. There are Super Heroes like Phil Packer and many others, but there are Heroes in your neighbourhood.

Now if anyone can give up a bit of time to help me find the stray arrows from the archery stall that would be great, two were last seen heading into orbit (which was pretty difficult as we were indoors). whilst other was seen heading towards an expert - it wasn’t me honest. I won’t be firing arrows at them, just rockets and not your Bonfire Night sorts either, Metaphoric Rockets (sounds like an 80’s Punk Band). Those are legal! And much, much bigger, not long before we light the touch paper…….

Those experts for the persecution have a lot to answer for, the more I live the more I learn from different sources there is no such thing as innocent till proven guilty. Thats a story for another day though.

 But I thought rather than my rantings, I would give you some more profound words, just to chew over… 

The probability that we may fall in the struggle ought not to deter us from the support of a cause we believe to be just; it shall not deter me

Abraham Lincoln

Truth will ultimately prevail where there is pains to bring it to light.
 

George Washington

Character, in the long run, is the decisive factor in the life of an individual and of nations alike.
 

Theodore Roosevelt

Believe nothing, no matter where you read it, or who said it, no matter if I have said it, unless it agrees with your own reason and your own common sense.
 

Buddha

Thanks for following and those that support and care, hats off to you. Causes like this are harder to support, much easier to support causes that involve saving the bomb or banning the whale (or something like that) but so many did and still do, it just shows amazing strength. To those True Believers, that dare to care, I salute you. 

Iain

 

Canadian News

Thursday, October 8th, 2009

Leading experts plan to meet in spring to review most contentious convictions in shaken baby cases
Oct 02, 2009 04:30 AM
One year after a groundbreaking report exposed flaws in Ontario’s forensic pathology system, investigations into dozens of cases continue, with a lawyer for victims of the notorious Dr. Charles Smith expecting more miscarriages of justice to be exposed.

“I’ve always guessed there will be several cases coming through the shaken-baby committee as likely miscarriages of justice,” James Lockyer said Thursday.

He was referring to a committee struck by the province last December to investigate 142 child deaths dating back to 1986 to determine if wrongful convictions resulted from what is now viewed as questionable science.

A review into the shaken-baby deaths was one of the recommendations contained in a report by Justice Stephen Goudge, who headed a public inquiry into Ontario’s troubled forensic pathology system. The inquiry was prompted by mistakes made by pathologist Dr. Charles Smith in 20 child-death investigations, 12 of which resulted in convictions.

Attorney General Chris Bentley said in an interview Thursday that cases that don’t involve issues of criminality or where the convicted person is deceased are being dropped from the probe.

The most contentious cases will then be reviewed by an international panel of leading medical experts, who are scheduled to meet in Toronto next spring.

“There’s no suggestion that anyone did anything wrong. It’s just that the knowledge of this shaken-baby syndrome has evolved over the years,” Bentley said.

New research shows that some babies once thought to have died from being violently shaken in fact suffered injuries as a result of falls.

Another committee struck by Bentley on the advice of Goudge is looking at 22 of Smith’s older cases that were not part of the public inquiry. These are child-death investigations Smith worked on between 1981 and 1991 and they are now being reviewed with a view to determining whether there were any miscarriages of justice.

Bentley said that in cases where injustice is being claimed, the Crown will respond expeditiously to any legal steps taken by the defence.

A third committee is advising Bentley on the viability of a potential compensation framework for Smith’s victims. It’s headed by Justice Coulter Osborne, with whom Bentley met on Wednesday.

“I know it’s a challenging issue. I’m hopeful,” Bentley said.

Already, two people convicted of homicide-related crimes on the basis of shaken-baby syndrome have come to the Association in Defence of the Wrongly Convicted for assistance, noted Lockyer, a director with the organization. Both are parents who did time in jail for the unrelated deaths of their children, one in the ’80s and the other in the ’90s.

“In cases where this pseudo-science was used to convict people of crimes of shaking which we can now say weren’t (shaking), of course they should be reviewed as likely miscarriages of justice,” Lockyer said.

Lawyer and child advocate Suzan Fraser said she hopes the province will also do something for siblings of dead children who were put up for adoption or into foster care after parents were wrongly implicated in child deaths.